(* This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or *)
(* modify it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public License *)
(* as published by the Free Software Foundation; either version 2.1 *)
(* of the License, or (at your option) any later version. *)
(* *)
(* This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, *)
(* but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of *)
(* MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the *)
(* GNU Lesser General Public License for more details. *)
(* *)
(* You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public *)
(* License along with this program; if not, write to the Free *)
(* Software Foundation, Inc., 51 Franklin St, Fifth Floor, Boston, MA *)
(* 02110-1301 USA *)
(* modify it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public License *)
(* as published by the Free Software Foundation; either version 2.1 *)
(* of the License, or (at your option) any later version. *)
(* *)
(* This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful, *)
(* but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of *)
(* MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. See the *)
(* GNU Lesser General Public License for more details. *)
(* *)
(* You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public *)
(* License along with this program; if not, write to the Free *)
(* Software Foundation, Inc., 51 Franklin St, Fifth Floor, Boston, MA *)
(* 02110-1301 USA *)
From Huffman Require Export OneStep HeightPred CoverMin OrderedCover SubstPred.
From Coq Require Import ArithRing Sorting.Permutation.
Set Default Proof Using "Type".
Section Build.
Variable A : Type.
Variable f : A -> nat.
Local Hint Constructors Permutation : core.
Local Hint Resolve Permutation_refl : core.
Local Hint Resolve Permutation_app : core.
Local Hint Resolve Permutation_app_swap : core.
Iterative the one step predicate
Inductive build : list (btree A) -> btree A -> Prop :=
| build_one : forall t : btree A, build (t :: []) t
| build_step :
forall (t : btree A) (l1 l2 : list (btree A)),
one_step f l1 l2 -> build l2 t -> build l1 t.
| build_one : forall t : btree A, build (t :: []) t
| build_step :
forall (t : btree A) (l1 l2 : list (btree A)),
one_step f l1 l2 -> build l2 t -> build l1 t.
Building gives a cover
Theorem build_cover : forall l t, build l t -> cover l t.
Proof.
intros l t H; elim H; clear H l t; auto.
intros t l1 l2 (l3, (t1, (t2, (HH, (HH1, HH2))))) H0 H1; try assumption.
apply cover_node with (1 := HH1); auto.
apply cover_permutation with (2 := HH2); auto.
Qed.
Proof.
intros l t H; elim H; clear H l t; auto.
intros t l1 l2 (l3, (t1, (t2, (HH, (HH1, HH2))))) H0 H1; try assumption.
apply cover_node with (1 := HH1); auto.
apply cover_permutation with (2 := HH2); auto.
Qed.
Building is compatible with the weight
Theorem build_comp :
forall (l1 l2 : list (btree A)) (t1 t2 : btree A),
build l1 t1 ->
build l2 t2 ->
weight_tree_list f l1 = weight_tree_list f l2 ->
same_sum_leaves f l1 l2 -> weight_tree f t1 = weight_tree f t2.
Proof.
intros l1 l2 t1 t2 H; generalize l2 t2; elim H; clear H l1 t1 l2 t2.
intros t l2 t2 H H0 (l3, (l4, (H1, (H2, H3)))).
generalize H0; inversion H; clear H0.
simpl in |- *; repeat rewrite <- plus_n_O; auto.
case H4.
intros l5 (t3, (t4, (H8, (H9, H10)))).
absurd (length l2 = length (t3 :: t4 :: l5)).
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := H2).
rewrite <- map_length with (f := sum_leaves f) (l := l4).
rewrite <- H3.
rewrite map_length with (f := sum_leaves f).
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := Permutation_sym H1).
simpl in |- *; red in |- *; intros; discriminate.
apply Permutation_length with (1 := H9).
intros t l1 l2 H H0 H1 l0 t2 H2 H3 H4.
inversion H2.
case H.
intros l5 (t3, (t4, (H8, (H9, H10)))).
case H4.
intros l6 (l7, (H11, (H12, H13))).
absurd (length l1 = length (t3 :: t4 :: l5)).
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := H11).
rewrite <- map_length with (f := sum_leaves f) (l := l6).
rewrite H13.
rewrite map_length with (f := sum_leaves f).
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := Permutation_sym H12).
rewrite <- H5; simpl in |- *; red in |- *; intros; discriminate.
apply Permutation_length with (1 := H9).
apply H1 with (1 := H6).
case one_step_comp with (3 := H) (4 := H5); auto.
case one_step_comp with (3 := H) (4 := H5); auto.
Qed.
forall (l1 l2 : list (btree A)) (t1 t2 : btree A),
build l1 t1 ->
build l2 t2 ->
weight_tree_list f l1 = weight_tree_list f l2 ->
same_sum_leaves f l1 l2 -> weight_tree f t1 = weight_tree f t2.
Proof.
intros l1 l2 t1 t2 H; generalize l2 t2; elim H; clear H l1 t1 l2 t2.
intros t l2 t2 H H0 (l3, (l4, (H1, (H2, H3)))).
generalize H0; inversion H; clear H0.
simpl in |- *; repeat rewrite <- plus_n_O; auto.
case H4.
intros l5 (t3, (t4, (H8, (H9, H10)))).
absurd (length l2 = length (t3 :: t4 :: l5)).
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := H2).
rewrite <- map_length with (f := sum_leaves f) (l := l4).
rewrite <- H3.
rewrite map_length with (f := sum_leaves f).
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := Permutation_sym H1).
simpl in |- *; red in |- *; intros; discriminate.
apply Permutation_length with (1 := H9).
intros t l1 l2 H H0 H1 l0 t2 H2 H3 H4.
inversion H2.
case H.
intros l5 (t3, (t4, (H8, (H9, H10)))).
case H4.
intros l6 (l7, (H11, (H12, H13))).
absurd (length l1 = length (t3 :: t4 :: l5)).
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := H11).
rewrite <- map_length with (f := sum_leaves f) (l := l6).
rewrite H13.
rewrite map_length with (f := sum_leaves f).
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := Permutation_sym H12).
rewrite <- H5; simpl in |- *; red in |- *; intros; discriminate.
apply Permutation_length with (1 := H9).
apply H1 with (1 := H6).
case one_step_comp with (3 := H) (4 := H5); auto.
case one_step_comp with (3 := H) (4 := H5); auto.
Qed.
Two built trees have same weight
Theorem build_same_weight_tree :
forall (l : list (btree A)) (t1 t2 : btree A),
build l t1 -> build l t2 -> weight_tree f t1 = weight_tree f t2.
Proof.
intros l t1 t2 H H0; apply build_comp with (l1 := l) (l2 := l); auto.
exists l; exists l; simpl in |- *; auto.
Qed.
forall (l : list (btree A)) (t1 t2 : btree A),
build l t1 -> build l t2 -> weight_tree f t1 = weight_tree f t2.
Proof.
intros l t1 t2 H H0; apply build_comp with (l1 := l) (l2 := l); auto.
exists l; exists l; simpl in |- *; auto.
Qed.
Building is compatible with permutation
Theorem build_permutation :
forall (l1 l2 : list (btree A)) (t : btree A),
build l1 t -> Permutation l1 l2 -> build l2 t.
Proof.
intros l1 l2 t H; generalize l2; elim H; clear H l1 l2 t; auto.
intros t l2 H; rewrite Permutation_length_1_inv with (1 := H); auto.
apply build_one.
intros t l1 l2 H H0 H1 l0 H2.
apply build_step with (l2 := l2); auto.
case H.
intros l3 (t1, (t2, (HH1, (HH2, HH3)))).
exists l3; exists t1; exists t2; repeat (split; auto).
apply Permutation_trans with (2 := HH2); auto.
apply Permutation_sym; auto.
Qed.
Definition obuildf :
forall l : list (btree A),
l <> [] -> ordered (sum_order f) l -> {t : btree A | build l t}.
Proof.
intros l; elim l using list_length_induction.
intros l1; case l1; clear l1.
intros H H0; case H0; auto.
intros b l0; case l0.
intros H H0 H1; exists b; auto.
apply build_one.
intros b0 l1 H H0 H1.
case (H (insert (le_sum f) (node b b0) l1)); auto.
rewrite <- Permutation_length with
(1 := insert_permutation _ (le_sum f) l1 (node b b0));
simpl in |- *; auto.
red in |- *; intros H2;
absurd
(length (node b b0 :: l1) = length (insert (le_sum f) (node b b0) l1)).
rewrite H2; simpl in |- *; intros; discriminate.
apply Permutation_length
with (1 := insert_permutation _ (le_sum f) l1 (node b b0));
simpl in |- *; auto.
apply insert_ordered; auto.
intros; apply le_sum_correct1; auto.
intros; apply le_sum_correct2; auto.
apply ordered_inv with (a := b0); auto.
apply ordered_inv with (a := b); auto.
intros t Ht; exists t.
apply build_step with (2 := Ht).
red in |- *; auto.
exists l1; exists b; exists b0; (repeat split; auto).
apply Permutation_sym; apply insert_permutation.
Defined.
forall (l1 l2 : list (btree A)) (t : btree A),
build l1 t -> Permutation l1 l2 -> build l2 t.
Proof.
intros l1 l2 t H; generalize l2; elim H; clear H l1 l2 t; auto.
intros t l2 H; rewrite Permutation_length_1_inv with (1 := H); auto.
apply build_one.
intros t l1 l2 H H0 H1 l0 H2.
apply build_step with (l2 := l2); auto.
case H.
intros l3 (t1, (t2, (HH1, (HH2, HH3)))).
exists l3; exists t1; exists t2; repeat (split; auto).
apply Permutation_trans with (2 := HH2); auto.
apply Permutation_sym; auto.
Qed.
Definition obuildf :
forall l : list (btree A),
l <> [] -> ordered (sum_order f) l -> {t : btree A | build l t}.
Proof.
intros l; elim l using list_length_induction.
intros l1; case l1; clear l1.
intros H H0; case H0; auto.
intros b l0; case l0.
intros H H0 H1; exists b; auto.
apply build_one.
intros b0 l1 H H0 H1.
case (H (insert (le_sum f) (node b b0) l1)); auto.
rewrite <- Permutation_length with
(1 := insert_permutation _ (le_sum f) l1 (node b b0));
simpl in |- *; auto.
red in |- *; intros H2;
absurd
(length (node b b0 :: l1) = length (insert (le_sum f) (node b b0) l1)).
rewrite H2; simpl in |- *; intros; discriminate.
apply Permutation_length
with (1 := insert_permutation _ (le_sum f) l1 (node b b0));
simpl in |- *; auto.
apply insert_ordered; auto.
intros; apply le_sum_correct1; auto.
intros; apply le_sum_correct2; auto.
apply ordered_inv with (a := b0); auto.
apply ordered_inv with (a := b); auto.
intros t Ht; exists t.
apply build_step with (2 := Ht).
red in |- *; auto.
exists l1; exists b; exists b0; (repeat split; auto).
apply Permutation_sym; apply insert_permutation.
Defined.
a function to buid tree from a cover list merging smaller trees
Definition buildf :
forall l : list (btree A), l <> [] -> {t : btree A | build l t}.
Proof.
intros l Hl; cut (isort (le_sum f) l <> []).
intros H1; cut (ordered (sum_order f) (isort (le_sum f) l)).
intros H2; case (obuildf (isort (le_sum f) l) H1 H2).
intros t H3; exists t; auto.
apply build_permutation with (1 := H3); auto.
apply Permutation_sym; apply isort_permutation; auto.
apply isort_ordered; auto.
intros; apply le_sum_correct1; auto.
intros; apply le_sum_correct2; auto.
contradict Hl; apply Permutation_nil; auto.
rewrite <- Hl; auto.
apply Permutation_sym.
apply isort_permutation; auto.
Defined.
forall l : list (btree A), l <> [] -> {t : btree A | build l t}.
Proof.
intros l Hl; cut (isort (le_sum f) l <> []).
intros H1; cut (ordered (sum_order f) (isort (le_sum f) l)).
intros H2; case (obuildf (isort (le_sum f) l) H1 H2).
intros t H3; exists t; auto.
apply build_permutation with (1 := H3); auto.
apply Permutation_sym; apply isort_permutation; auto.
apply isort_ordered; auto.
intros; apply le_sum_correct1; auto.
intros; apply le_sum_correct2; auto.
contradict Hl; apply Permutation_nil; auto.
rewrite <- Hl; auto.
apply Permutation_sym.
apply isort_permutation; auto.
Defined.
Merging smaller trees gets the tree of mimimal weight for the given cover
Theorem build_correct :
forall (l : list (btree A)) (t : btree A),
l <> [] -> build l t -> cover_min _ f l t.
Proof.
intros l; elim l using list_length_ind.
intros l0 H t H0 H1.
case (cover_min_ex _ f) with (1 := H0); auto.
intros t1 (Ht1, Ht2).
case cover_ordered_cover with (1 := Ht1); auto.
intros l1 (Hl1, Hm1).
case (ordered_cover_height_pred A 0) with (1 := Hm1).
intros ln0 Ht3.
case exist_first_max with ln0.
apply height_pred_not_nil1 with (1 := Ht3); auto.
intros a (ln1, (ln2, (HH1, (HH2, HH3)))).
cut (length ln0 = length l1);
[ intros IL | apply height_pred_length with (1 := Ht3) ].
rewrite HH1 in Ht3; rewrite HH1 in IL; clear HH1 ln0.
case height_pred_disj_larger with (1 := Ht3); auto.
intros (ln3, HH4); rewrite HH4 in HH3; rewrite HH4 in IL; rewrite HH4 in Ht3;
clear HH4 ln2; auto.
case same_length_ex with (1 := IL); auto.
intros l2 (l3, (t4, (HM1, (HM2, HM3)))).
generalize HM2 HM3; case l3; try (simpl in |- *; intros; discriminate);
clear HM2 HM3 l3.
intros t5 l3 HM2 HM3; rewrite HM3 in Ht3; rewrite HM3 in IL;
rewrite HM3 in Hm1; rewrite HM3 in Hl1; clear HM3 l1.
cut
(exists b1,
(exists c1,
(exists l4,
Permutation (l2 ++ t4 :: t5 :: l3) (b1 :: c1 :: l4) /\
ordered (sum_order f) (b1 :: c1 :: l4)))).
intros (b1, (c1, (l4, (HC1, HC2)))).
case
prod2list_reorder2
with (l1 := ln1) (l2 := ln3) (5 := HC1) (6 := HC2) (a := a);
auto with datatypes.
intros b H2; apply Nat.lt_le_incl; auto with arith.
intros l5 (l6, (HB1, (HB2, (HB3, HB4)))).
case height_pred_subst_pred with (1 := Ht3) (l2 := l5 ++ b1 :: c1 :: l6);
auto.
rewrite <- IL; repeat rewrite app_length; simpl in |- *; auto.
intros t6 (HD1, HD2).
case (buildf (l5 ++ node b1 c1 :: l6)); auto.
case l5; simpl in |- *; intros; discriminate.
intros t7 HD3.
case H with (3 := HD3); auto with arith.
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := Hl1).
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := HC1).
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := HB3).
repeat rewrite app_length; simpl in |- *; auto with arith.
case l5; simpl in |- *; intros; discriminate.
intros HD4 HD5.
split; auto.
apply build_cover with (1 := H1).
intros t0 H2; apply Nat.le_trans with (weight_tree f t1); auto.
rewrite (build_same_weight_tree l0 t t7); auto.
apply Nat.le_trans with (weight_tree f t6).
apply HD5; auto.
apply ordered_cover_cover.
apply (height_pred_ordered_cover A 0 (ln1 ++ pred a :: ln3)); auto.
apply height_pred_shrink with (b := a); auto.
replace (weight_tree f t1) with (0 * sum_leaves f t1 + weight_tree f t1);
[ idtac | simpl in |- *; auto ].
rewrite height_pred_weight with (1 := Ht3).
replace (weight_tree f t6) with (0 * sum_leaves f t6 + weight_tree f t6);
[ idtac | simpl in |- *; auto ].
rewrite height_pred_weight with (1 := HD1); auto.
apply build_step with (2 := HD3); auto.
exists l4; exists b1; exists c1; repeat (split; auto).
apply Permutation_trans with (1 := Hl1).
apply Permutation_sym; apply Permutation_trans with (1 := HB3).
apply Permutation_sym; apply Permutation_trans with (1 := HC1); auto.
apply Permutation_trans with ((node b1 c1 :: l6) ++ l5); auto.
simpl in |- *; apply perm_skip.
apply Permutation_cons_inv with c1.
apply Permutation_cons_inv with b1.
apply Permutation_sym; apply Permutation_trans with (1 := HB3).
apply (Permutation_app_swap l5 (b1 :: c1 :: l6)).
generalize (isort_permutation _ (le_sum f) (l2 ++ t4 :: t5 :: l3));
generalize
(isort_ordered _ (sum_order f) (le_sum f) (le_sum_correct1 _ f)
(le_sum_correct2 _ f) (l2 ++ t4 :: t5 :: l3)).
case (isort (le_sum f) (l2 ++ t4 :: t5 :: l3)); auto.
intros H2 H3.
absurd (l2 ++ t4 :: t5 :: l3 = []); auto.
case l2; simpl in |- *; intros; discriminate.
apply Permutation_sym in H3.
apply Permutation_nil with (1 := H3).
intros b l4; case l4.
intros H2 H3; absurd (l2 ++ t4 :: t5 :: l3 = b :: []).
case l2; simpl in |- *; try (intros; discriminate).
intros b0 l5; case l5; try (intros; discriminate).
apply Permutation_length_1_inv with (1 := Permutation_sym H3).
intros b0 l5 H2 H3; exists b; exists b0; exists l5; auto.
intros ((H2, (H3, H4)), H5); split.
apply build_cover with (1 := H1).
intros t2 H6; rewrite <- cover_one_inv with (t1 := t1) (t2 := t2).
rewrite <- cover_one_inv with (t1 := t1) (t2 := t); auto.
rewrite <- H5; apply cover_permutation with (2 := Hl1); auto.
apply build_cover with (1 := H1).
rewrite <- H5; apply cover_permutation with (2 := Hl1); auto.
Qed.
forall (l : list (btree A)) (t : btree A),
l <> [] -> build l t -> cover_min _ f l t.
Proof.
intros l; elim l using list_length_ind.
intros l0 H t H0 H1.
case (cover_min_ex _ f) with (1 := H0); auto.
intros t1 (Ht1, Ht2).
case cover_ordered_cover with (1 := Ht1); auto.
intros l1 (Hl1, Hm1).
case (ordered_cover_height_pred A 0) with (1 := Hm1).
intros ln0 Ht3.
case exist_first_max with ln0.
apply height_pred_not_nil1 with (1 := Ht3); auto.
intros a (ln1, (ln2, (HH1, (HH2, HH3)))).
cut (length ln0 = length l1);
[ intros IL | apply height_pred_length with (1 := Ht3) ].
rewrite HH1 in Ht3; rewrite HH1 in IL; clear HH1 ln0.
case height_pred_disj_larger with (1 := Ht3); auto.
intros (ln3, HH4); rewrite HH4 in HH3; rewrite HH4 in IL; rewrite HH4 in Ht3;
clear HH4 ln2; auto.
case same_length_ex with (1 := IL); auto.
intros l2 (l3, (t4, (HM1, (HM2, HM3)))).
generalize HM2 HM3; case l3; try (simpl in |- *; intros; discriminate);
clear HM2 HM3 l3.
intros t5 l3 HM2 HM3; rewrite HM3 in Ht3; rewrite HM3 in IL;
rewrite HM3 in Hm1; rewrite HM3 in Hl1; clear HM3 l1.
cut
(exists b1,
(exists c1,
(exists l4,
Permutation (l2 ++ t4 :: t5 :: l3) (b1 :: c1 :: l4) /\
ordered (sum_order f) (b1 :: c1 :: l4)))).
intros (b1, (c1, (l4, (HC1, HC2)))).
case
prod2list_reorder2
with (l1 := ln1) (l2 := ln3) (5 := HC1) (6 := HC2) (a := a);
auto with datatypes.
intros b H2; apply Nat.lt_le_incl; auto with arith.
intros l5 (l6, (HB1, (HB2, (HB3, HB4)))).
case height_pred_subst_pred with (1 := Ht3) (l2 := l5 ++ b1 :: c1 :: l6);
auto.
rewrite <- IL; repeat rewrite app_length; simpl in |- *; auto.
intros t6 (HD1, HD2).
case (buildf (l5 ++ node b1 c1 :: l6)); auto.
case l5; simpl in |- *; intros; discriminate.
intros t7 HD3.
case H with (3 := HD3); auto with arith.
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := Hl1).
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := HC1).
rewrite Permutation_length with (1 := HB3).
repeat rewrite app_length; simpl in |- *; auto with arith.
case l5; simpl in |- *; intros; discriminate.
intros HD4 HD5.
split; auto.
apply build_cover with (1 := H1).
intros t0 H2; apply Nat.le_trans with (weight_tree f t1); auto.
rewrite (build_same_weight_tree l0 t t7); auto.
apply Nat.le_trans with (weight_tree f t6).
apply HD5; auto.
apply ordered_cover_cover.
apply (height_pred_ordered_cover A 0 (ln1 ++ pred a :: ln3)); auto.
apply height_pred_shrink with (b := a); auto.
replace (weight_tree f t1) with (0 * sum_leaves f t1 + weight_tree f t1);
[ idtac | simpl in |- *; auto ].
rewrite height_pred_weight with (1 := Ht3).
replace (weight_tree f t6) with (0 * sum_leaves f t6 + weight_tree f t6);
[ idtac | simpl in |- *; auto ].
rewrite height_pred_weight with (1 := HD1); auto.
apply build_step with (2 := HD3); auto.
exists l4; exists b1; exists c1; repeat (split; auto).
apply Permutation_trans with (1 := Hl1).
apply Permutation_sym; apply Permutation_trans with (1 := HB3).
apply Permutation_sym; apply Permutation_trans with (1 := HC1); auto.
apply Permutation_trans with ((node b1 c1 :: l6) ++ l5); auto.
simpl in |- *; apply perm_skip.
apply Permutation_cons_inv with c1.
apply Permutation_cons_inv with b1.
apply Permutation_sym; apply Permutation_trans with (1 := HB3).
apply (Permutation_app_swap l5 (b1 :: c1 :: l6)).
generalize (isort_permutation _ (le_sum f) (l2 ++ t4 :: t5 :: l3));
generalize
(isort_ordered _ (sum_order f) (le_sum f) (le_sum_correct1 _ f)
(le_sum_correct2 _ f) (l2 ++ t4 :: t5 :: l3)).
case (isort (le_sum f) (l2 ++ t4 :: t5 :: l3)); auto.
intros H2 H3.
absurd (l2 ++ t4 :: t5 :: l3 = []); auto.
case l2; simpl in |- *; intros; discriminate.
apply Permutation_sym in H3.
apply Permutation_nil with (1 := H3).
intros b l4; case l4.
intros H2 H3; absurd (l2 ++ t4 :: t5 :: l3 = b :: []).
case l2; simpl in |- *; try (intros; discriminate).
intros b0 l5; case l5; try (intros; discriminate).
apply Permutation_length_1_inv with (1 := Permutation_sym H3).
intros b0 l5 H2 H3; exists b; exists b0; exists l5; auto.
intros ((H2, (H3, H4)), H5); split.
apply build_cover with (1 := H1).
intros t2 H6; rewrite <- cover_one_inv with (t1 := t1) (t2 := t2).
rewrite <- cover_one_inv with (t1 := t1) (t2 := t); auto.
rewrite <- H5; apply cover_permutation with (2 := Hl1); auto.
apply build_cover with (1 := H1).
rewrite <- H5; apply cover_permutation with (2 := Hl1); auto.
Qed.
Final function that tree of minimal weight for the cover